Main | Katrina Response Wasn't Racist »
October 7, 2005
Is there ever a proper time for war?
The question of whether our soldiers should be in Iraq fighting a war of attrition continues to surface, but, no matter which side you take, it seems to be a peripheral question to the real dilemma.
That being, for Americans, is there ever a time for war anymore?
It seems our country is caught between knowing all wars are abominations, and knowing there are situations where we believe we will lose our free and open way of life if we don't fight.
We have a split personality. Intellectually we know wars have very seldom settled anything, but sometimes our human animal instincts say, "This is not a time for flight."
To find the elusive answer, we have to ask why is it we won World War II, but faltered in Korea, Vietnam, and in the first Iraq war?
First, in WWII we were attacked by a major power, and something we tend to forget is that we could have lost that war.
At that time, there was a perception in the country by most people that to lose the war meant to lose America. Right or wrong, the people were predominantly behind the war.
We geared up, we sent the troops, we fought the war, and we showed the enemy that we were not afraid to totally annihilate him if it came to that. Two atomic bombs showed, Japan directly and Germany indirectly, it was surrender or be decimated.
We won.
What has changed since then that keeps bogging our soldiers down in distant lands where they sit as targets for "insurgents?"
In World War II, Americans felt the crush of having been attacked directly.
We didn't feel that in Korea, Vietnam, or the first war in Iraq, and it translated into a lack of popular support for those wars. Korea remains un-ended in an armistice, Vietnam was lost, and the first Iraq war was ended short of Baghdad.
But that isn't the answer, because on 9-11 there was most assuredly a direct attack on the United States prior to our current war, and still polls show that the majority of Americans want out of Iraq.
Either we didn't feel the attack came from the country with which we went to war, (sort of if when Japan attacked us, we went to war with Turkey.) or there is some other answer. The other answer is that our country no longer has an "end game" in war.
The end game in wars that have succeeded has always had to do with proving you are willing to annihilate the other side.
In order for Americans to allow that, there has to be a clear and present danger.
We live in a society which will not allow that end game because
as Americans we feel it is wrong unless it is in self-defense.
That is why we continue to fight half-way wars and continue to falter after the initial assault even though we are a superior military force.
To make matters worse, when the other side doesn't believe we will actually win it, it does what has been done in all wars since WWII.
In Korea, Vietnam, Iraq-one, the enemy has always known if it holds out long enough we will go away, and we have. They say the same thing now of the insurgent war in Iraq.
They are right. The United States, for all its military might, as a country, feels that to annihilate another country is wrong, unless the clear and present danger is that they will annihilate us if we don't.
The government hasn't proven that lately.
If we go to war we must fight to win; if we don't, we will lose.
The answer seems evident. There is never a time for war unless you must win it at all costs. War doesn't work part way.
Most of us believe that somewhere high in government there is information they don't share with us. If this is true, they should make it much clearer to us now than they have.
If some major terror war, beginning somewhere in the 1940s is culminating in the likes of Osama bin Laden and Ayman al-Zawahri and is bent on the total destruction of the United States and our way of life, show us the proof. Make it clear, and it will be a time for war.
If not, we as a society that is truly different from any other that has ever existed, will not allow the necessary end game of war.
We will fight with half our strength and half our weapons and will take care not to hurt civilians and places of culture and religion. And we will lose.
If history has taught us anything, if religion has taught us anything, if the ideal of America has taught us anything, it is that there is a time for peace and a time for war.
We have also, obviously, been taught that if the situation doesn't merit an end game, it is not a time for war.
Posted by Hourihan on October 7, 2005 12:03 PM
Comments
Welcome aboard, John! :-)
Posted by: Rene at October 7, 2005 4:42 PM
Best of the text i read about a problem.
Posted by: rape stories at June 1, 2006 3:37 AM
We are wellocme to it's configuration.
Posted by: gay rape at June 2, 2006 7:24 PM
Greatings to you. Can you help me to find any more info?
forced sex movies
Posted by: forced sex movies at June 11, 2006 10:08 PM
Your article is prety nice. It's a pity that i didn't see it more later.
Posted by: rape stories at June 19, 2006 8:15 PM
Persone los pioneros non rabata. Great...
Posted by: teen lesbian rape at June 20, 2006 11:01 AM
Your article is quite right, thanks.
Posted by: rape videos at July 7, 2006 1:52 AM
Quarta Legge di Parkinson:
Il numero di persone in ogni gruppo di lavoro tende ad aumentare
indipendentemente dal lavoro che deve essere svolto.
http://buycialis.5p.org.uk/ buy cialis cheap cialisDei turisti raccolgono un bambino di nove anni tutto bagnato, sporco ed
infreddolito che sta camminando lungo una strada di notte.
"Cosa ti e' successo?", gli chiedono.
"Tutte le sere mio padre mi porta al lago con la macchina e, dopo avermi
portato nel bel mezzo con la barca, mi butta dentro. Io devo nuotare
fino a riva e poi camminare fino a casa".
"Deve essere molto dura per un bambino come te!".
"No", risponde lui, "l'unica cosa difficile e' uscire dal sacco".
-- Da http://www.e-link.ch/jack/jokes-i/jokes-i.sht
cialis online order cialis http://buycialis.5p.org.uk/ Quarta Legge di Parkinson:
Il numero di persone in ogni gruppo di lavoro tende ad aumentare
indipendentemente dal lavoro che deve essere svolto.
Posted by: order cialis online at August 19, 2006 1:00 AM
Is patented too? Must be fucked also.
From: Genome
http://melchiorre.blog.espresso.repubblica.it/buy-propecia.html buy propecia cheap propecia The bigger the theory the better.
propecia order propecia http://melchiorre.blog.espresso.repubblica.it/buy-propecia.html Is patented too? Must be fucked also.
From: Genome
Posted by: buy propecia order propecia at September 6, 2006 10:43 PM
Very good content best all.
Posted by: cheap hydrocodone online at October 15, 2006 6:50 AM

