« Thoughts on Tuesday | Main | Best "Heroes" EVER!!!!!!!!! »
February 26, 2007
"Donnellys" derivative, but entertaining
It's hard to know how to review the new NBC drama "The Black Donnellys." On the one hand, the series, which follows four Irish brothers embroiled in a life of crime, is ambitious for a network drama. One of its main characters is a drug addict who shows no signs of getting clean. And its protagonist, Tommy Donnelly (Jonathan Tucker) goes from good-guy aspiring artist to avenging killer within the space of the show's pilot. Plus, it's fairly entertaining, with lots of action and even some witty dialogue.
But, and this is a huge but, it's so deriative that it's impossible to watch "Donnellys" without thinking of other, better entries in the "gangster drama" genre.
For instance, Tommy is a good boy and upstanding citizen dragged into a life of crime by his family, drawing an obvious parallel to the classic film "The Godfather." It also features characters with colorful nicknames, like Louie Downtown and Joey Ice Cream (hints of "The Sopranos" and "Goodfellas"). In fact, the show borrows from "Goodfellas" most of all, with a chatty narrator, pop songs that provide dramatic accompaniment to the moments of violence, and stylish editing.
Yet, the show is all surface, and has hardly any of the depth of these works that inspired it. The show is co-created by Paul Haggis, who brought us the Oscar-winning movie "Crash," a solid, but overrated film that made its points about racism a little too easily.
"Donnellys" also feels a little too easy, with its reliance on our affection for mob movies and TV shows.
Yet, I can't completely dismiss it. There are moments that are genuinely affecting, such as Tommy's ill-fated love affair with nice girl Jenny (Olivia Wilde), who loves Tommy, but can't quite stomach his descent into crime. Also, the always-reliable Kate Mulgrew is on hand as the Donnellys protective mama who at least seems like a semi-original creation, rather than a Livia Soprano clone.
"Donnellys" is worth a look if you don't mind its constant borrowing from superior works, or if you've never seen a Scorcese film or a single episode of "The Sopranos."
"The Black Donnellys" premieres 10 p.m. tonight on NBC.
Posted by amanda on February 26, 2007 8:07 AM
Comments
Post a comment
Thanks for signing in, . Now you can comment. (sign out)
(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)
